Every horn play-tested / Worldwide shipping / Trade-ins welcome
Guides & Advice
← All posts
← Previous article | Next article →

Vintage Saxophone Buying Guide: Conn vs Buescher vs Martin vs King

If you are looking for a vintage American saxophone, four names appear again and again: Conn, Buescher, Martin and King.

All four manufacturers produced professional instruments that are still highly regarded today, but they are not interchangeable.

They developed different bore designs, keywork, mechanisms and tonal personalities.

Some players want the huge, open sound associated with a vintage Conn. Others prefer the refinement of a Buescher, the concentrated power of a Martin or the immediacy of a King.

There is no universal winner.

The better question is: which vintage American saxophone suits the way you want to play?

A quick comparison

Brand General character Ergonomics Value Models to know
Conn Broad, powerful, open and colourful Distinctly vintage on earlier models Varies from affordable to highly collectible New Wonder II, 6M, 10M
Buescher Focused, warm, refined and flexible Older on True Tones, more familiar on later models Often excellent value True Tone, Aristocrat, Big B, 400
Martin Rich, centred, powerful and complex Distinctive but generally manageable Often good value compared with equivalent prestige models Handcraft, Committee II, Committee III
King Immediate, lively, projecting and responsive Generally more familiar on later models Zephyrs can offer value, Super 20s can be expensive Zephyr, Super 20

These descriptions are only broad tendencies. Individual saxophones can vary considerably, especially after many decades of playing, repair and restoration.

Conn - big, open and unmistakably vintage

Conn is one of the most important names in American saxophone history.

C.G. Conn produced instruments in Elkhart, Indiana, and some of its saxophones from the 1920s through to the 1950s have become classics.

If you ask vintage saxophone players to describe the typical Conn sound, words such as big, broad, open and powerful come up frequently.

Good Conns can feel extremely free-blowing.

They can produce a huge amount of sound when pushed while still responding beautifully at low volume.

Conn New Wonder II

The New Wonder II is one of the best-known early Conn designs.

These instruments are often informally called "Chu Berry" saxophones, especially the tenors, although that was never an official Conn model name.

They are very much vintage instruments in both appearance and ergonomics.

Features may include:

The keywork can initially feel unusual to a player accustomed to a modern saxophone, but many players adapt quickly.

Conn 6M alto

The 6M developed the Conn alto into a more refined instrument while retaining much of the company's characteristic sound.

Many examples feature the famous "Naked Lady" engraving.

The 6M is particularly attractive to players who want a classic American vintage sound but prefer something a little more evolved mechanically than an early New Wonder.

Conn 10M tenor

The 10M is the tenor counterpart most commonly associated with the same period.

It has become one of the classic American vintage tenor saxophones.

Good examples can produce an enormous, rich sound and are particularly popular among players who enjoy an open, flexible response.

What are the disadvantages of a vintage Conn?

Ergonomics are the biggest issue for some players.

The left-hand little-finger cluster on many Conns is quite different from modern Selmer-style keywork.

Some players dislike it immediately.

Others stop noticing it after a few days.

Rolled tone holes also need to be in good condition. Damage or poor previous repair around a rolled tone hole can make pad seating more complicated.

Who should consider a Conn?

A Conn is particularly worth trying if you want:

Buescher - refined, flexible and often excellent value

Buescher is another major Elkhart manufacturer and one of the most interesting brands in the vintage market.

The company produced saxophones over a long period, and its best instruments are capable of competing with much more expensive vintage models.

Bueschers are often associated with a warm, focused and refined sound.

They can still be powerful, but the character is often different from the huge spread of a Conn.

Buescher True Tone

The True Tone was produced through several generations.

Later examples can be excellent instruments and often represent very good value.

They retain older-style ergonomics, but good examples can be wonderfully responsive.

The True Tone is particularly interesting for someone who wants a genuinely early vintage saxophone without necessarily paying the premium attached to more fashionable models.

Buescher Aristocrat

The Aristocrat represented an important step forward in Buescher design.

These saxophones are often highly regarded for their combination of tone, response and increasingly refined keywork.

Different generations vary, so it is important to identify the exact version rather than assume every Aristocrat is the same.

Buescher Big B

The Big B is one of the most visually recognisable Buescher designs because of the large "B" engraving on the bell.

Good examples are highly desirable among vintage players.

They can combine a rich sound with relatively practical ergonomics and strong build quality.

Buescher 400

The Buescher 400 series includes some of the company's most distinctive instruments.

Depending on the period, they can feature unusual bell key layouts and elaborate visual details.

Good 400s are serious professional saxophones and can be extremely impressive players.

Snap-in pads and Norton springs

Buescher used some unusual engineering features that are worth understanding before buying one.

Many instruments used:

When these systems are complete and functioning correctly, they are excellent.

Missing original components can make restoration more complicated.

That does not mean a Buescher without its original pad system is automatically a bad instrument, but originality matters more on collectible examples.

Who should consider a Buescher?

A Buescher is particularly attractive if you want:

Buescher is one of the brands I would particularly recommend exploring if you want a high-quality vintage saxophone without automatically paying collector-level prices.

Martin - rich, powerful and full of character

Martin saxophones tend to inspire strong loyalty among players who discover them.

They are not always as instantly recognisable as Conn or Selmer, but good Martins can be outstanding instruments.

The typical Martin character is often described as rich, centred, complex and powerful.

Rather than the broad spread of some Conns, a Martin can feel more concentrated while still producing an enormous amount of sound.

Martin Handcraft

The Handcraft name covers several periods and designs.

Earlier Handcraft instruments can have distinctly vintage ergonomics, but they are often beautifully made and can be excellent players.

As with many long-running model names, the exact serial number and period matter when identifying what you are looking at.

Martin Committee II

The Committee II is one of Martin's better-known professional designs.

These instruments can offer excellent value compared with some better-known vintage models.

They have a strong following among players who appreciate Martin's particular tonal character.

Martin Committee III - The Martin

The later Committee III is often simply called "The Martin", reflecting the prominent bell engraving.

It is probably the Martin model most modern vintage players are familiar with.

Good examples can have a rich, muscular and highly expressive sound.

They are capable of subtle playing but also respond extremely well when pushed.

Soldered tone holes

One distinctive feature of many Martin saxophones is the use of soldered tone holes.

Rather than drawing the tone holes directly from the body tube, Martin made them separately and soldered them into position.

This construction method is not inherently a problem.

It was simply part of Martin's design.

However, on neglected instruments, old solder joints should be checked for leaks or movement.

Who should consider a Martin?

A Martin may suit you particularly well if you want:

King - immediate, lively and powerful

King saxophones were produced by the H.N. White Company in Cleveland, Ohio.

King developed a particularly strong reputation for professional instruments that combined power, response and craftsmanship.

Good Kings often feel very immediate.

The sound seems to arrive quickly and can project extremely well.

King Zephyr

The Zephyr is an important professional King model and can be a very interesting vintage purchase.

Good examples can offer much of the classic King character without the price attached to the most desirable Super 20s.

As with other vintage models, production period matters.

Earlier and later Zephyrs can differ in specification and desirability.

King Super 20

The Super 20 is King's most famous saxophone.

It was used by major professional players and became known for its combination of projection, responsiveness and distinctive construction.

Some examples feature:

Early and highly original Super 20s can command substantial prices.

For many players, though, the attraction is not collectability but the way the instrument responds.

Who should consider a King?

A vintage King may be particularly appealing if you want:

Which has the most modern ergonomics?

This depends heavily on the period.

As a general rule, later instruments from all four manufacturers tend to feel more familiar to modern players than their earliest designs.

If moving directly from a modern saxophone, many players may find:

However, hand size and personal technique matter enormously.

A mechanism that one player dislikes may feel completely natural to another.

Which has the biggest sound?

This is subjective, but Conn probably has the strongest reputation for an exceptionally broad, open sound.

A good vintage Conn can feel huge.

Martin can be equally powerful but often in a more centred or concentrated way.

King instruments are known for projection and immediacy.

Buescher often feels more focused and refined, although that does not mean it lacks power.

The mouthpiece, reed and player can change all of these characteristics substantially.

Which is best for jazz?

All four.

These instruments were built during periods when jazz, dance bands and popular music were central to saxophone playing.

Each brand has been used successfully in professional settings.

Your choice should depend more on the sound and feel you want than the label on the bell.

Which is best for a beginner?

Condition matters more than brand.

A properly restored vintage saxophone can be suitable for a beginner, but I would generally favour an instrument with relatively manageable ergonomics and stable response.

A later Buescher Aristocrat, Martin or King may feel more immediately familiar than a very early Conn or True Tone.

That said, a beginner should not be discouraged from an older design if the instrument fits comfortably and plays easily.

Which offers the best value?

This changes constantly depending on market demand.

In broad terms, Buescher and Martin can often offer particularly good value because they do not always attract the same premium as the most fashionable Conn, King or Selmer models.

King Zephyrs can also be strong value compared with Super 20s.

Some Conn models remain surprisingly affordable considering their quality.

The best bargains are often instruments that are excellent players but sit slightly outside the most collectible serial ranges or specifications.

Which is most collectible?

All four manufacturers produced collectible instruments.

Collector value depends on:

A pristine original King Super 20 may attract substantial collector interest.

So can particularly desirable Conns, Big B Bueschers and rare Martins.

But collectability and playability are not always the same thing.

Condition matters more than brand

This cannot be emphasised enough.

A badly leaking Conn 6M is not automatically a better purchase than a properly restored Buescher simply because you prefer the Conn reputation.

A famous King with major neck damage can be a far worse purchase than an unfashionable Martin in excellent condition.

Before buying any vintage saxophone, check:

Conn vs Buescher

If choosing between Conn and Buescher, I would think mainly about tonal character and ergonomics.

Conn often offers the broader and more open experience.

Buescher often feels more focused and refined.

Both manufacturers produced superb professional saxophones.

Martin vs King

Martin and King can both provide plenty of power.

Martin often has a dense, complex core to the sound.

King can feel more immediate and projecting.

Again, these are broad tendencies rather than strict rules.

Conn vs Martin

This can be an especially interesting comparison for players who want a large American sound.

Conn may feel wider and more spread.

Martin may feel more centred while still producing enormous depth and power.

The playing sensation can be very different even when both instruments sound equally impressive from the listener's perspective.

Buescher vs King

Buescher and King represent two rather different approaches.

Buescher can offer warmth, refinement and flexibility.

King can offer immediacy, projection and excitement.

Neither is better.

They simply encourage different playing experiences.

Which one should you buy?

If possible, play them.

Vintage saxophones are individual instruments.

Two examples of the same model can feel surprisingly different after 70 or 90 years of use.

If you cannot play before buying, pay close attention to:

Do not buy purely because one brand has the strongest reputation online.

The best vintage American saxophone is the one you want to keep playing

Conn, Buescher, Martin and King all produced outstanding saxophones.

They simply approached the instrument differently.

Choose Conn if you love the idea of a broad, open and unmistakably vintage sound.

Explore Buescher if you want refinement, flexibility and often excellent value.

Try Martin if you are attracted to a rich, powerful sound with a strong centre.

Look at King if immediacy, projection and a lively response appeal to you.

But do not let those descriptions make the decision for you.

With vintage saxophones, the individual instrument always matters more than the name engraved on the bell.

The right one is the saxophone that makes you want to keep playing it.

You can browse the current selection of vintage saxophones for sale at Vintage Sax Studio, including instruments from Conn, Buescher, Martin, King and other vintage manufacturers.

You may also be interested in The Best Vintage Saxophone Brands to Look For, What to Look for When Buying a Vintage Saxophone and Are Vintage Saxophones a Good Investment?.

← All posts
← Previous article | Next article →